4

Well, integration testing supposed to be the testing of integrated components.

Contract testing supposed to be testing of the way components interact with each other (API).

But what the main difference? It seems to be the same thing! Well, okay, are checking two integrated components, example. Anyway, we make them interact with each other. But they interact via API. So, what is the difference?

4

Martin Fowler has a good article just about that

Quoting him:

Integration tests collect modules together and test them as a subsystem in order to verify that they collaborate as intended to achieve some larger piece of behaviour.

While:

Whenever some consumer couples to the interface of a component to make use of its behaviour, a contract is formed between them. This contract consists of expectations of input and output data structures, side effects and performance and concurrency characteristics.

When the components involved are microservices, the interface is the public API exposed by each service. The maintainers of each consuming service write an independent test suite that verifies only those aspects of the producing service that are in use

These tests are not component tests. They do not test the behaviour of the service deeply but that the inputs and outputs of service calls contain required attributes and that response latency and throughput are within acceptable limits.

To summarize it, integrations tests are about functionality while contract tests are about the interface, or the "language" the two sides speak.

PACT (a common contract testing framework) also have a good explanation to why Contract Tests are not Functional Tests from their point of view:

Contract tests focus on the messages that flow between a consumer and provider, while functional tests also ensure that the correct side effects have occured.

| improve this answer | |
2

The term "Integration checking" are usually misused.

Rainsberger has a seminal post called Integrated Tests are a Scam. By "Integrated" he means what is usually called "integration; he uses integration as @Reijmersdal did: If things can connect together.

Contract checking is, here, a type of integration checking. It's about checking if the syntax the interfaces of two components match - no semantic validation happens here: Because well-uncoupled components shouldn't care about correctness in the behavior of external components, only if they can connect correctly.

Think about this as building a lego structure:

  • Component/unit check: You analyze a single lego piece;
  • Contract check: You analyze if two lego pieces at the time can connect to each other;
  • Integrated check: You connect two or more lego pieces and analyze it as a single piece.

The problem with integrated checking is that the number of possibilities grows necessarily asymptotically exponentially to the number of pieces. Unit / Component grows linearly to the number of pieces. Contract checking may grow as integrated does, but that's highly unlikable because each piece will probably connect to just a handful of other pieces.

| improve this answer | |
1

For me integration testing means testing how multiple microservices integrate to eachother and facilitate a user-workflow. With the goal of finding configuration and wiring issues.

For me contract testing means testing a single microservice API. Testing inputs and outputs of a single service to see if it meets its documented contract. This could be using a mocked storage and a fake consumer or provider. Now I could test a consumer and its provider seperatly and verify they stick to their contracts. This means they "should" work together.

Contract-based test suites are combined to cover each interaction scenario that takes place between the consumer and provider endpoints

...

Contract-based tests typically won't detect endpoint configuration issues or misused classes.

https://techbeacon.com/app-dev-testing/end-end-vs-contract-based-testing-how-choose

Problem with terminolgy is that it could mean something different in different context, different teams, different companies, different industries.

Other reads: https://martinfowler.com/bliki/ContractTest.html

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.